


There is a strong national and international commitment to large-scale carbon removal from the atmosphere (Carbon Dioxide Removal, CDR) to achieve the climate goals. But how do you responsibly do that? A study commissioned by the Climate Research Initiative Netherlands (KIN), led by the University of Twente, shows which ecological and social effects and preconditions must be taken into account.
The report 'What could responsible CDR policy and research look like in the Netherlands? An exploratory report with recommendations for policy and research' resulted from a study carried out by the University of Twente, Delft University of Technology and Deltares. It explores the possibilities for large-scale scaling up of carbon removal in the Netherlands. CDR has moved up the political agenda, including in the most recent National Climate Plan of the Dutch government. Organisations such as the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) and the Scientific Climate Council (WKR) argue that large-scale carbon removal is likely to be necessary to meet the climate goals of the Paris Agreement. This mainly involves removing CO2 emissions that cannot be prevented by means of emission reduction at the source (the so-called 'overshoot').
Researchers still have many questions about the large-scale application of CDR technologies, especially about their potential negative environmental and societal effects. They see a major risk in a focus on a broad deployment of carbon removal, which can inadvertently come at the expense of efforts to reduce CO2 emissions themselves (also referred to as 'mitigation deterrence'). Another aspect that needs to be looked at, according to the researchers, is the large claim that CDR can place on land, water, raw materials and on the energy supply in a small and densely populated country like the Netherlands. This in turn can have an effect on shifting the burden (possibly unfairly) to other regions of the world, for example for the extraction of necessary raw materials. The researchers conclude that none of the available CDR technologies is currently ready to achieve the desired scale-up in the Netherlands.
To achieve responsible CDR upscaling, the researchers argue, a well-thought-out policy framework is needed in advance, which approaches these aspects not only from a technological, but also from a social, ecological and system perspective. This can prevent the cure being worse than the disease.
The University of Twente led this research and contributed to this report from various disciplines, including the technical sciences, geosciences, social sciences and humanities. In addition to discussing the technical aspects of CDR, the researchers were able to shed important light on the societal, ecological and ethical aspects of carbon removal. Furthermore, societal stakeholders were involved through interviews with stakeholders and a workshop. In this way, different scientific disciplines and perspectives from society have been brought together.
The report makes it clear that there are still many questions to be answered before the Netherlands can achieve a responsible, fair and environmentally friendly scaling up of CDR. In addition to six principles for responsible CDR policy, the report provides five recommendations for follow-up research on knowledge gaps found. Based on the findings from this report, the KIN wants to further stimulate research, practice and politics to take the right paths for responsible CDR. So that CDR can really contribute to a sustainable society for the future.
The report, as well as the summaries in Dutch and English, can be found on the website of the Library of the University of Twente and here on the KIN website. Contact person at the UT: Nicole Huijts (n.m.a.huijts@utwente.nl).